ZeroToVPN
VPN Comparison 2026

ProtonVPN vs Surfshark

Comprehensive comparison of features, pricing, speed, and security to help you choose the best VPN for your needs.

ProtonVPN

Rating: 4.5/5
Best Price:$2.49/mo
Servers:15,000+
Countries:120
Speed Score:88%

Surfshark

Rating: 4.6/5
Winner
Best Price:$1.99/mo
Servers:4,500+
Countries:100
Speed Score:90%

Based on our comprehensive testing, Surfshark comes out ahead overall.

Last updated: April 2026

Detailed Feature Comparison

Feature
ProtonVPN
Surfshark
Overall Rating
4.5/5
4.6/5
Monthly Price
$9.99/mo
$15.45/mo
Best Price (2yr plan)
$2.49/mo
$1.99/mo
Money-Back Guarantee
30 days
30 days
Free Tier
Total Servers
15,000+
4,500+
Countries
120
100
Simultaneous Devices
10
Unlimited
Speed Score
88%
90%
Security Score
99%
95%
Streaming Score
80%
92%
Protocols
WireGuardOpenVPNIKEv2
WireGuardOpenVPNIKEv2
Encryption
AES-256
AES-256
Kill Switch
No-Logs Policy
Netflix Support
Torrenting Support
Get Started
Read Review
Read Review

Pros and Cons

ProtonVPN

Pros

  • Free tier available (no data limits)
  • Based in privacy-friendly Switzerland
  • Open source and audited
  • Secure Core servers
  • Integrates with ProtonMail

Cons

  • Free tier has limited servers
  • Streaming support is inconsistent
  • Fewer server locations

Surfshark

Pros

  • Unlimited simultaneous connections
  • Very affordable long-term plans
  • Good streaming support
  • CleanWeb ad blocker included
  • Camouflage mode for extra privacy

Cons

  • Smaller server network
  • Speeds can vary
  • Based in the Netherlands (14 Eyes)

Final Verdict

Surfshark comes out ahead in this comparison with a higher overall rating of 4.6/5 compared to ProtonVPN's 4.5/5. Best value VPN with unlimited device connections.

Choose ProtonVPN if:

  • You need stronger security (99%)
  • You want more server options (15,000+ servers)

Choose Surfshark if:

  • You prioritize faster speeds (90%)
  • You're looking for better value ($1.99/mo)

ProtonVPN

4.5/5 Rating$2.49/mo
Read Full Review

Surfshark

4.6/5 Rating$1.99/mo
Read Full Review

Frequently Asked Questions

Is ProtonVPN better than Surfshark?+
Surfshark is rated higher overall with a score of 4.6/5 compared to ProtonVPN's 4.5/5. Surfshark Best value VPN with unlimited device connections. However, both VPNs have their strengths, so your best choice depends on your specific needs.
Which is cheaper, ProtonVPN or Surfshark?+
Surfshark is the more affordable option at $1.99/mo on a 2-year plan, compared to ProtonVPN at $2.49/mo. Surfshark offers better value on long-term plans, though both services frequently run promotional discounts.
Which is faster, ProtonVPN or Surfshark?+
Surfshark achieves a higher speed score of 90% in our tests, compared to ProtonVPN's 88%. Surfshark uses modern VPN protocols that minimize speed loss, making it the better choice for bandwidth-heavy activities like 4K streaming and large file downloads.
Does ProtonVPN or Surfshark have more servers?+
ProtonVPN has a larger server network with 15,000+ servers, compared to Surfshark's 4,500+ servers. More servers generally means less congestion and more location choices, giving you better connection reliability and more options for bypassing geo-restrictions.
Which VPN is better for streaming, ProtonVPN or Surfshark?+
Surfshark scores higher for streaming at 92% compared to ProtonVPN's 80%. Surfshark reliably unblocks popular streaming platforms and maintains fast enough speeds for HD and 4K content without buffering.

Compare More VPNs

Not sure yet? Check out our full VPN comparison tool or read detailed reviews of each service.

View All ComparisonsSee Best VPNs 2026

Related Content

Surfshark vs ProtonVPN
Compare

Surfshark's unlimited devices vs ProtonVPN's Swiss privacy — which is the better pick?

Read more
ProtonVPN Review
Review

Our in-depth review of ProtonVPN — rated 4.5/10 for speed, security, and value.

Read more
Surfshark Review
Review

Our in-depth review of Surfshark — rated 4.6/10 for speed, security, and value.

Read more
NordVPN vs Surfshark
Compare

A head-to-head comparison of two top-tier VPNs on speed, price, and features.

Read more
Best VPN Services
Best Pick

Our expert ranking of the top VPN providers based on speed, security, and value.

Read more
Best Free VPNs
Best Pick

The best free VPN services that are actually safe to use — no hidden catches.

Read more